Cafe Serendipity Menu
Cafe Serendipity, nestled in Newton, NJ, offers a warm, family-owned deli experience that shines with fresh, quality ingredients. Their menu features standout items like freshly made cheesesteaks, which have been praised for their home-cooked taste and affordable prices. Breakfast lovers will appreciate all-day options including crispy bacon, Taylor Ham, and flavorful Western omelets, even if some rolls and sides could see minor improvements.
The versatility here is notable—beyond classic sandwiches, the buffalo chicken wonton bites and fresh tacos bring exciting variety. The atmosphere is clean and inviting, complemented by friendly staff who add a personal touch to each visit. Whether stopping for a quick breakfast or a satisfying lunch, the genuine freshness and consistent flavors make Cafe Serendipity a delightful new favorite in the Newton food scene.
House Specialties
Lunch Menu
Breakfast Sandwiches
Soup of the Day
Wraps
Drinks
Breakfast Bagels
Cold Sandwiches - Sub
Cold Sandwiches - Sandwich
Omelets
Salads
Sides
From the Grill
House Specialties
Chicken Tacos
US$13.95
Italian Sub
US$11.95
Steak Tacos
US$14.95
Chicken Nachos
US$14.95
Beef Empanadas
US$2.75
Tuna Melt
US$11.95
Chicken Empanadas
US$2.25
Tacos Al Pastor
US$12.95
Cuban Sandwich
US$13.95
BBQ Burger
US$14.95
Chicken Parm Sandwich
US$12.95
Steak Quesadilla
US$14.95
Hampton Boy
US$12.95
Leah's Cheeseburger
US$13.95
Chicken Cheesesteak
US$13.95
The Nelson Slammin Steak
US$14.95
Grilled Chicken Panini
US$13.95
Chuck Sandwich On Ciabatta Bread
US$13.95
Pastrami Reuben
US$13.95
Juan Wrap
US$13.95
Chicken Quesadilla
US$12.95
Chipotle Cheestek
US$14.95
Meat & Cheese Panini
US$13.95
Cheesesteak
US$13.95
Hamburger
US$10.95
The Milton Sandwich
US$11.95
Lunch Menu
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg & Cheese With Hash Browns
US$8.95
Breakfast Bowl
US$11.95
Western Sandwich
US$9.95
Fat Pat
US$10.95
Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese With Hash Browns
US$8.95
Hampton House Sandwich
US$9.75
Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese
US$7.25
Bacon, Egg & Cheese
US$7.25
Burrito Wrap
US$12.95
Sausage, Egg & Cheese
US$7.25
Early Bird
US$9.95
Breakfast Sub
US$10.95
Country Breakfast Platter
US$10.95
Hampton House Platter
US$12.95
Sausage, Egg & Cheese With Hash Browns
US$8.95
Chicken Pastina
US$7.95
Chili
US$6.95
Kale Bean Soup
US$6.95
Soup of the Day
Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap
US$12.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
US$12.95
Mexican Wrap
US$14.95
King Kong Wrap
US$12.95
Niceldi's Wrap
US$12.95
Chicken House Wrap
US$13.95
Chicken Fajita Wrap
US$12.95
Snapple
US$2.95
Soda
US$3.25
Tropicana Orange Juice
US$2.95
Nesquick
US$2.95
Pure Leaf
US$3.25
Arizona
US$2.00
Red Bull
US$3.95
Gatorade
US$3.25
Monster
US$3.95
Sunny D
US$2.65
Drinks
Breakfast Bagels
Double Egg With Taylor Ham
US$6.25
Turkey Bacon Egg Cheese
US$8.75
Breakfast Bagels With Butter
US$2.95
Cream Cheese
US$3.25
Double Egg With Ham
US$5.50
Double Egg With Cheese
US$5.95
Butter And Jelly
US$2.95
Double Egg On A Bagel Or Roll
US$4.95
Scallion Cream Cheese
US$3.95
Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese
US$3.95
Cream Cheese And Jelly
US$3.50
Steak, Egg,& Cheese
US$8.95
Double Egg With Sausage
US$6.50
Pimento Olive Cream Cheese
US$3.95
Add Bacon
US$2.00
Turkey
US$10.25
Tuna
US$10.25
Roast Beef
US$11.95
Ham
US$10.25
Chicken Salad
US$10.25
Add Cheese
US$1.00
Cold Sandwiches - Sub
Cold Sandwiches - Sandwich
Roast Beef
US$9.25
Tuna
US$8.25
Chicken Salad
US$8.25
Add Cheese
US$1.00
Add Bacon
US$2.00
Turkey
US$8.25
Ham
US$8.25
Wester Omelet
US$10.95
Texas French Toast With Meat
US$9.99
Pancakes
US$7.75
Cheese Omelet
US$8.95
Spinach & Mozzarella Cheese Omelet
US$10.95
Texas French Toast
US$7.99
Veggie Omelet
US$10.95
Pancakes With Meat
US$9.95
Omelets
Salads
Mexican Salad
US$13.95
Chicken Caesar Salad
US$12.95
Buffalo Chicken Salad
US$13.95
BBQ Chicken Salad
US$12.95
Cobb Salad
US$14.95
Add Grilled Chicken Additional
US$3.50
Garden Salad
US$8.25
Chef Salad
US$12.95
Chicken Fingers With French Fries
US$12.95
Side Of Home Fries
US$4.95
Side Of Bacon, Taylor Ham Or Sausage
US$5.95
Hash Browns
US$4.95
Sweet Potato
US$6.75
Chicken Wings Buffalo Or Plain
US$14.95
French Fries
US$5.95
Chicken Fingers
US$10.95
Mozzarella Sticks
US$8.95
Onion Rings
US$8.25
Sides
From the Grill
BLT
US$9.50
Grilled Cheese With Bacon
US$10.95
Grilled Cheese With Tuna
US$10.95
Grilled Cheese With Tomato
US$8.95
Grilled Cheese With Ham
US$9.95
Grilled Cheese
US$8.95